HomeTalent ManagementFirst Look With Dom Smales: The Death of the Brand Deal

First Look With Dom Smales: The Death of the Brand Deal

Dom Smales on why the sponsored post model is breaking down and what brands, creators and talent managers must build next.

The sponsored post built this industry. It will not carry it into the next decade.

For fifteen years the creator economy grew so fast on a simple trade: a brand paid a creator, the creator posted and an engaged audience did the rest. I helped build that model and in fact, brokered the first deal between a creator and a brand in Europe in 2010. It worked because attention was organic and trust came free with it. This is what lit the touch paper of the multi-billion-dollar industry we all work in today.

A friend of mine, Jan Rezab, sent me a deck recently supporting his new business Ravineo (shout out to Jan). Jan founded, built and then exited Socialbakers, the social media analytics platform that helped make “engagement rate” a standard metric in the first place. The thread of the deck was that attention on Meta’s platforms is under pressure, and therefore the exchange between a brand and a creator is evolving.

That bargain is breaking and the data now says so. Jan’s 2026 research puts Instagram “Following” reach at 13%, down from 90% in 2016. The feed people actually see is 57% algorithm, 30% ads and only 13% the accounts they chose to follow. Put another way, 87% of what reaches an audience is now set by the algorithm and by paid media. The follower base a creator spent a decade building barely touches the feed anymore. We’ve sensed this for a while but now it’s really clear, and it’s worrying. This whole industry is built on organic attention and a real and trusted relationship between a creator and their audience. This is now much less important than it ever was.

Here is the figure that should worry every manager and every brand in the industry: global time spent on social media peaked in 2022 and has been flat, or slightly down, ever since. Attention stopped growing. The money, however, did not. Across the same years Meta’s ad revenue climbed from roughly $84bn in 2020 to around $196bn in 2025. More money is chasing a pool of attention that has stopped expanding, so the price of reaching anyone only goes one way: up.

Which means the reach a creator once delivered for nothing, and therefore sold as their value to a brand, now has to be bought with paid media. When a brand pays for the post and then pays again to make anyone see it, the brand deal stops being a deal. It becomes a media cost with a person attached. This only erodes the value of the creator and their audience.

The industry has noticed, and its two loudest answers both fall short.

The first answer is to measure it better. When reach goes dark and the old engagement rate stops meaning anything, the instinct is to reach for sharper analytics. That instinct is right and you can no longer afford to fly blind. But measurement is the first step, not the destination. It tells you more precisely how much you are overpaying. It does not change what you are paying for.

The second answer is build a bigger machine. The case everyone points to comes from one of the huge beauty and personal care brands: 835 million influencer reach, more than a thousand creators and 1,800 branded reels in 90 days. It is genuinely impressive. It is also, underneath the scale, the same transaction repeated at industrial volume. Boosted Partnerships, where a brand pays to push out a creator’s post, grew by more than 100% year on year and made up something like $10bn of ad revenue in a single quarter. That is not a new model. It is the old model with a bigger invoice.

And this is the direction of travel. Jan’s Ravineo expects partnership ads to reach almost a quarter of the feed by 2028. In some categories the tipping point has already passed: in TikTok beauty in Italy, influencer ads are the majority of what people see, ahead of the brands’ own ads. The boosting machine is not a clever workaround for the collapse of organic reach. It’s becoming the whole game.

So the question is not whether the sponsored post is dying. It is. The question is what brands build in its place. I think four things matter (but I would love to hear your thoughts too):

Build original entertainment properties that star creators, rather than renting a slot on their feed. Own the format, own the IP and the audience comes to you instead of being bought back every quarter. See GloMotion Studios. Managers should be pitching talent owned formats to their best brand partners. 

Put creators on the cap table. A creator with equity is not a vendor reading a script. They are a founder with a reason to care about the brand for ten years, not ten days.

Build the brand and curate the editorial with creators, not around them. Their taste is the product. Use it to shape what you make, not just to caption what already exists.

And treat media and organic as one strategy, not two budgets. The smartest brands will use paid distribution to put sharper creative in front of sharper audiences, not to inflate a post that was never going to travel.

When Gleam Futures started, we focussed on building legacy IP for our roster. We wanted them better resourced, more famous and more organised, so we could build brands together. Personal, retail and entertainment brands. I think the next phase is about doing that again. The marketing industry has fully committed now. The last ten years of “brand deals” were about that consolidation, but now it’s time for us to build together again.

The brand deal got us here. It will not get us there. The brands that win the next era will stop hiring creators to talk about products and start building things with them worth talking about.

Author

  • Dom Smales

    Dom Smales founded Gleam Futures in 2010, Europe's first creator management company. Over the following decade, he built the business into a global market leader before selling and exiting in 2021. Since the earliest days of the creator economy, Dom has been at the forefront of the industry's evolution. Today, as Co-Founder of GloMotion Studios and Founder of WinnieWood, he builds, invests in and advises the next generation of creator-led businesses and ideas. Through First Look, he shares his observations and perspectives on where the industry is heading next and what that means for brands, creators and investors alike.

    Connect with Dom on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dom-s-ab90124/

Dom Smales
Dom Smales
Dom Smales founded Gleam Futures in 2010, Europe's first creator management company. Over the following decade, he built the business into a global market leader before selling and exiting in 2021. Since the earliest days of the creator economy, Dom has been at the forefront of the industry's evolution. Today, as Co-Founder of GloMotion Studios and Founder of WinnieWood, he builds, invests in and advises the next generation of creator-led businesses and ideas. Through First Look, he shares his observations and perspectives on where the industry is heading next and what that means for brands, creators and investors alike. Connect with Dom on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dom-s-ab90124/
- Advertisment -spot_img
- Advertisment -spot_img

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img
RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img
- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments